Photo by nappy from Pexels
Ideas for Leaders #779

Growth Mindset, Empathy and Training for Entrepreneurial Mentoring

This is one of our free-to-access content pieces. To gain access to all Ideas for Leaders content please Log In Here or if you are not already a Subscriber then Subscribe Here.

Key Concept

Mentees with a growth mindset, mentors driven by empathy and a desire to give, and program administrators who invest in training for mentors and mentees on how to best leverage mentoring relationships are leading success factors for entrepreneurial mentorship programs.

Idea Summary

Mentors with extensive entrepreneurial experience can make a significant contribution to the success of new or less experienced entrepreneurs facing the inevitable setbacks of early stage ventures. Many entrepreneurial mentoring relationships, however, rarely reach their full potential. 

Research from the University of Michigan, INSEAD, and the Entrepreneur Futures Network, based on an extensive survey of mentors, mentees and mentoring program administrators in 33 U.S. mentoring programs, highlights some key factors for successful mentoring relationships.

Formal training. The research found that formal training and mentor education is lacking across the board. In general, aside from basic orientations offered by some, entrepreneurial mentoring programs don’t educate mentors and mentees on how to pull the greatest benefit from the mentoring relationship. Simply connecting an experienced entrepreneur with a student or budding entrepreneur will yield disappointing results for all parties involved. 

Personal attributes of mentors. In addition to experience and knowledge, the best mentors share a common set of personal attributes essential for productive mentoring. In general, the most sought-after qualities in a mentor are being trustworthy, empathetic, a good listener and an effective communicator. Empathy, that is, truly caring for the mentee, is emphasized; some volunteers for mentorship are more concerned about what the program can do for them—in terms of recognition, contacts and other benefits—than what it can do for the mentee.  

The researchers summarized the best attributes of the mentor as someone who 

  • inspires curiosity 
  • challenges assumptions and expectations (gives feedback) 
  • guides through asking probing questions
  • is honest and direct about what he or she doesn’t know
  • is eager to learn along with the mentee

A growth mindset in mentees.  Mentors and mentees agree that the core contribution of a mentor is to provide guidance. There is some disagreement, however, of the form that this guidance should take. Many mentees are looking for specific information and advice, and direct answers to their questions. Mentors on the other hand believe that an indirect approach—helping the mentees learn by asking them probing questions and encouraging reflection—is the way to create successful entrepreneurs. 

The issue of providing answers vs. asking questions is more than a process issue. It reflects a fundamental difference in mindset. Mentees who prefer questions and opportunities for reflection have a growth mindset: they believe that entrepreneurs have skills that can be developed and learned, and that mentors offer a path to the acquisition of those skills. In contrast, mentees without a growth mindset view their mentors more narrowly as information and advice sources. Mentees with a growth mindset see more value in mentoring programs than their non-growth mindset counterparts. 

Intensity of interactions. The research covers university entrepreneurial mentoring programs and well as non-university programs. One difference between the two is the intensity of interactions. Interactions in non-university programs are much higher than in university programs, which increases the value of the collaboration between mentor and mentee—especially given that non-university programs are often able to recruit more experienced mentors. Low mentee motivation (students may not intend to start entrepreneurial businesses), poor mentee-mentor fit, or insufficient training on effective mentoring relationships contribute to the lower intensity of interactions in university programs.

Networking opportunities. Especially for mentees in non-university settings, the opportunity to be introduced to the network of their mentors—to meet potential customers, suppliers, investors and partners—is considered by mentees one of the most value-adding outcomes of the mentoring relationship.     

A voice in matching. The importance of involving mentors and mentees in the matching process cannot be overlooked. The more mentors and mentees participate in choosing their partners in the mentoring relationship, the more they are satisfied with the relationship.

Business Application

The important role that mentors play in developing new entrepreneurial talent is unquestioned. This research reveals, however, some of the challenges faced by program administrators, mentors and mentees as they strive to maintain productive mentoring relationships. 

Non-university mentorship programs fare better than university programs according to the study. In thriving entrepreneurial ecosystems — Silicon Valley is a shining example — companies are willing to invest in strong mentoring programs, recognizing their fundamental contribution to success. 

The research suggests the following approaches and best practices for creating a high-performance entrepreneurial mentoring program:

  • Begin with developing an opening training session on mentoring. Both mentors and mentees need to understand why and how to develop relationships and mentoring approaches that give them the perspective, mindset and tools to succeed.
  • Recognize the growth mindset as a desirable personality attribute of candidates for mentoring relationships, and reinforce this mindset in the introductory training as well as in ongoing program remainders and tips. Help mentees recognize the value of a mentor who is asking questions to enhance their growth, rather than just giving direct advice.
  • Focus on enabling a closer collaboration between mentee and mentor, with a high number of interactions. One way to facilitate collaboration and more productive exchange between the partners is to invest in better online systems and resources; although personal interactions are best, video interactions create stronger relationships than simple emails. 
  • Give mentors and mentees a voice in the choice of their partners in the mentoring relationship as opposed to unilaterally imposing the match. 
Contact Us

Authors

Institutions

Source

Idea conceived

  • November 2017

Idea posted

  • November 2020

DOI number

10.13007/779

Subject

Real Time Analytics