Alice and the Queen of Hearts
Ideas for Leaders #511

Bossy: What’s Gender Got to Do with It?

This is one of our free-to-access content pieces. To gain access to all Ideas for Leaders content please Log In Here or if you are not already a Subscriber then Subscribe Here.

Key Concept

Bossy is not a synonym for assertiveness, or other positive executive leadership skills, and women are labelled bossy in the workplace more often than men are. But what lessons can be learned — for both genders — from  this blatant, and damaging, double-standard?

Idea Summary

The Center for Creative Leadership (CCL®) conducted research on the role of the word bossy in the workplace. Their results show a consistent trend that being bossy in the workplace has negative consequences, and those consequences are particularly harsh for women.

Bossy coworkers are described as unpopular and unlikely to be successful in the future. Acting bossy is related to being seen as less promotable by bosses for both men and women. However, the relationship was stronger for women.

Bossy women coworkers are seen as more unpopular and less successful compared to bossy men coworkers. And yet when researchers looked at bossy behaviors - without the bossy label - men are just as likely as women to act bossy in the workplace.

The earliest citation of bossy in the Oxford English dictionary refers to a sentence from 1882 stating “There was a lady manager who was dreadfully bossy.” Use of the word bossy peaked in the 1930s (when women were often accused of ‘stealing’ male jobs) and in the 1970s (when the women’s movement led to an increase of women in the workplace).

The word bossy, and its link to leadership, was brought into fresh focus by the ‘Ban Bossy’ campaign founded by Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg. Prominent backers - including Condoleezza Rice, Anna Maria Chávez, Michelle Obama, and Beyoncé - helped amplify the core message viz that from a young age, girls are trained to be quiet and submissive. When women break gender norms, they are often criticized, disliked, and called bossy - a word that discourages women from aspiring to lead.

Men who are labelled as bossy or who act in bossy ways are not rewarded in the workplace. They too are seen as unpopular, unsuccessful, and not promotable—just to a lesser extent compared to women.

The six key indicators of bossiness:

  1. Bossy people control others and dictate orders.
  2. Bossy people ignore others’ perspectives.
  3. Bossy people are rude and pushy towards others.
  4. Bossy people micromanage and prescribe specific actions (e.g., saying exactly how or when something should be done).
  5. Bossy people are focused on authority, power, and status.
  6. Bossy people interact in aggressive ways.

Business Application

The word bossy describes a pattern of poor interpersonal skills. This is a serious problem in the workplace. Research has shown that failing to manage interpersonal relationships at work predicts leadership derailment - the situation in which high-potential leaders end up getting fired or barred from promotion.

  • Being bossy is a sign of bad leadership. Therefore, leaders should make an effort to avoid being bossy at work regardless of gender.
  • The word bossy is disproportionately used towards women. Therefore, leaders should be cautious about using it in the workplace.
  • When giving feedback about interpersonal issues, try to use other, more descriptive words instead - such as the six bossy indicators identified above.
  • Interpersonal skills matter in the workplace. Therefore, it is important for aspiring leaders to learn and develop strong interpersonal skills.

In the past some might have been tempted to encourage women to be “more like men” in order to create more women leaders. However, when it comes to being bossy, being more like men is not likely to get women very far. If anything, research suggests that men need to focus on not being bossy just as much as women do in order to become more effective, and more promotable, leaders.

Contact Us

Authors

Institutions

Source

Idea conceived

  • May 2015

Idea posted

  • May 2015

DOI number

10.13007/511

Subject

Real Time Analytics